This year (2008), two new food storage cookbooks were introduced – Simple Recipes Using Food Storage published by Cedar Fort, Inc. (CFI) and Simple Recipes Using Basic Food Storage by Karen Keenan. At first glance, these books looked like the same book in different formats so I bought both to compare.
The two books are, indeed, essentially the same thing. They both approach food storage with a very helpful “step” system and both provide tips for using food storage foods. They have a similar number of recipes and over 2/3 of the recipes in each book are identical to those in the other book. Some have different names but are the same recipes. The biggest differences lie in the remaining recipes (in Step 5 of both and Step 7/Part 2) and in a few other parts of both books.
What’s the same?
Recipes in both books seem to be very doable. There is a variety and the recipes will help you learn to use storage foods better. Both teach about sprouting and both teach about gluten but the recipes using them are different. Both books do use a lot of fresh and frozen ingredients in the last section of recipes (Step 7 and Part 2) which I tend to take issue with in a food storage cookbook. There are many recipes you would find in a typical ward Relief Society cookbook but that does show you that it’s easy to incorporate food storage foods into daily menus.
Both books need to work on recipe formatting. They both also have recipes whose results would be questionable if the powdered or dried form of an ingredient was used instead of the fresh one asked for. There are also recipes (found in Step 2 of each book which recommends adding powdered eggs) that would not work with powdered eggs unless you could find dried egg yolks and dried egg whites. The use of powdered eggs in uncooked foods is also questionable from a food safety perspective.
Keenan’s book puts most of the tips in the front of the book. Be sure to read through that section as it will help with the rest of the book. This book does not have an index but it has a more detailed table of contents and the recipes in Part 2 are categorized – main dish, soup, bread, desserts, etc. One nice feature in this book is that after the list of foods recommended in each step, there is a list of recipes or dishes you can now prepare with those additional foods in your storage. Keenan also breaks down the category “spices and flavorings” in her steps. Rather than getting all of them all at once, she recommends a gradual accumulation according to the recipes in that section or step. That always has a less painful affect on your food budget since those small items can be expensive. Keenan has recipes for soy beans in this book but also has more of the recipes you would find in a ward cookbook.
Send mail to
questions or comments about this web site.